If European clubs had World Rugby rankings

Note: if you want to just see a (completely unofficial and experimental) European clubs ranking the table is at the bottom of this post.

Love them or loathe them, World Rugby’s rankings have become a regular talking point during international windows. Not just the preserve of boring stattos like myself, the rankings are now used for determining World Cup groups, so attract interest and speculation particularly ahead of the pool draws.

The choice of opposition and timing of international games can have a significant effect. A nation fielding a second-string side against a lower tier nation risks a big hit to their position; on the other hand regularly playing higher ranked teams may cause only a negligible loss of ranking points – but consistently losing those games means not gaining any points either. Summer tours in Lions years often see the former, Wales’ annual inability to beat Australia perhaps an example of the latter.

As in any league table, teams can find themselves rising and falling without having played, as other teams win and lose. The heavy weighting of World Cup games can shape the rankings for some time after a World Cup, which is probably intentional, but can sometimes seem to penalise teams who lose in the knock-out stages.

No ranking system is perfect and one obviously cannot take into account the often subjective context of each game. Despite its flaws, those of us with a predilection for stats and league tables can’t help but be drawn to them, as evidenced by the number of rankings calculators on the web.

The domestic season can be very different to the international. Line-ups are more changeable and upsets more common, as teams who’ve made trips to Siberia or a wet and windy Galway can attest. Losing international players for several weeks mid-season can have a large effect on some teams, less so on others. As a result, ranking positions seem less entrenched – there is no New Zealand to dominate the top spot year after year.

Ospreys vs Castres. Image by Marc (flickr, creative commons).

The table below represents a World Rugby style ranking system for European club teams from the start of the 2015/16 season to 18/03/2017. It is based only on games in the English Aviva Premiership, Guinness Pro 12, French Top 14, European Champions and European Challenge cups. Play-offs and knock-out rounds were given a higher weighting, as world cup games are for international teams.

The loss of international players to the Six Nations appears to have taken its toll on some clubs. Despite being a top 4 Premiership side, Bath have plummeted down the rankings after a loss to lowly Bristol and a home hammering from Wasps. The French big guns seem lower than expected – perhaps because of losses in European competitions, or perhaps because the Top 14 play more games during international windows. (Would the French care even if these rankings had a practical use?)

With more points awarded for league play-offs and knock-out stages it will be interesting to see how the rankings look in May. As one would expect, Saracens had a clear lead at the end of last season after their league and European cup double. If the Ospreys triumph in the Challenge Cup, will it give them an inflated ranking for what is essentially a second-tier tournament? Are the 3 domestic leagues really comparable in strength? What will become of Stade Français and Racing Metro 92? Will Zebre ever move off the bottom?

1 Munster 59.08
2 Leinster 57.91
3 Exeter Chiefs 57.45
4 Ospreys 57.11
5 Saracens 56.83
6 Wasps 56.41
7 La Rochelle 56.21
8 Scarlets 55.74
9 Clermont Auvergne 54.62
10 Montpellier 53.61
11 Castres 53.5
12 Ulster 52.92
13 Northampton Saints 52.09
14 Connacht 52.06
15 Glasgow 51.99
16 Toulon 51.11
17 Brive 50.91
18 Cardiff Blues 50.48
19 Lyon 50.36
20 Leicester Tigers 50.3
21 Pau 50.27
22 Harlequins 49.98
23 Bath Rugby 49.8
24 Toulouse 48.81
25 Racing Metro 48.79
26 Stade Français 48.73
27 Bordeaux Begles 48.04
28 Gloucester Rugby 47.98
29 Newcastle Falcons 47.97
30 Edinburgh 47.67
31 Worcester Warriors 47.63
32 Sale Sharks 47.46
33 Grenoble 46.44
34 Dragons 46.32
35 Bayonne 45.34
36 Timisoara Saracens 45.05
37 Bristol 44.54
38 London Irish 44.34
39 Calvisano 44.34
40 RC Enisei 44.32
41 Agen 43.02
42 Benetton Treviso 42.14
43 Oyonnax 41.95
44 Zebre 41.38

The above rankings were worked out using my code library here:

The results for the past 2 seasons were taken from a variety of sources, including ESPN Rugby, Planet Rugby and the API at drop22.net.

Image of Toulon fans by Alasdair Massie on flickr.

Image of a wet Ospreys vs Castres lineout by Marc on flickr.

World Rugby’s explanation of their ranking system here.

Rugby Vision have their own different set of rankings here, which look like they were based on an Elo-type system.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s